South Shian

Shian means "Fairy Hill"

In |The Jew's Harp in the Law, 1590–1825 by Michael Wright, Source: Folk Music Journal, Vol. 9, No. 3 (2008), pp. 349-371

Some time in the intervening eighteen days it had come to the notice of the justice, John Campbell of Moy, that Mcllmichall had been consorting with evil spirits. Mcllmichall, under interrogation, confessed to a series of meetings that took place in and around Appin from November 1676 to February 1677, at some of which he played Jews harps. On Sunday, 20 November 1676 he had been travelling from Ardtur, about a mile north of Port Appin, south to Glackriska, on Loch Crenan opposite the island of Eriska. Somewhere (and he claimed that he had become lost) he had seen candle lights on a hill and a large number of men and women dancing. He was spotted by the participants, and there was a discussion among them as to whether they should invite him in, after which the leader, who appeared to be a large, ruddy-faced, old man, dressed as a corporal guardsman, asked Mcllmichall to come back on the following Sunday. The defendant confessed that he 'judges them not to have bein wordlie men or men ordayned of god, and that they enquyred if he wes baptized and that he said he wes'.

THE JEW'S HARP IN THE LAW, 1590-1825 359
In spite of the leader having told Mcllmichall he must keep their meetings secret, he confided in a certain Robert Buchanan, and he was punished for this by the distinctly unimpressed fairies, who gave him a beating. Nevertheless, he continued to meet with the dancers on a number of other occasions up until 2 February 1677. The meetings always took place on Sundays, sometimes on the island of Lismore or at a well-known fairy mound, the Shian of Barcaldine, on the south side of Loch Crenan, where, while the others danced, 'he played on trumps'.36 This implies that he played more than one Jews harp. Playing two Jews harps, one in each hand, is a known technique, practised by skilled players, particularly in Austria today and in Ireland in the recent past.
The information regarding Donald Mcllmichall comes from a single source, the Highland Papers.

Highland Papers, ed. byj. R. N. Macphail, Publications of the Scottish History Society, 2nd series, vols 5, 12, 20, 3rd series, vol. 22, 4 vols (Edinburgh: Scottish History Society, 1914-34), III, Highland Papers, III, 37-38.

At his trial he was asked : Interrogat if he mett with them in other places Answers that he mett them in Leismore and at the Shian of Barcalden and still saw the old man that seemed to be cheif being ane large tall corporal Gardman and ruddie and he was engadgeit to conceal them and no to tell other. Bot that he told it to the forsaid Robert Buchanan once fer which he was reproved and stricken be them in the cheik and other pairts, and that he mett them still on ilk Sabaths nights and that he playd on trumps to them quhen they danced.

In view of his confessions, the jury had no hesitation in finding Donald Mcllmichall guilty of the theft of the cow and of consorting with evil spirits.
He was executed on Monday, 19 November 1677

Other references to Donald include
Canon J. A. MacCulloch paper called 'The Mingling of Fairy and Witch Beliefs in Sixteenth and Seventeenth Century Scotland', in 1921, wrote, 'Donald MacMichael, told how he had entered a fairy hill, where dancing was going on … One of the fairy women engaged Donald to return eight nights after. He obeyed and was in the hill for a month, playing the "trumps" while the fairies danced.'

Canon J. A. MacCulloch, 'The Mingling of Fairy and Witch Beliefs in Sixteenth and Seventeenth Century Scotland, Folklore, 32 (1921), 227-44 (p. 238).
Henderson and Cowan, p. 62.
I. F. Grant, Highland Folk Ways (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1961), p. 135;

Henderson and Cowan : Donald Mclllmichall's first sighting he saw them dancing by candlelight. On subsequent visits he playd on trumps to them quhen they danced'.39

Two finds of Jew's harps (TRUMPS have been made at Achandun Castle, on the island of Lisemore.


22 June 1774
The meeting appoints that the ferrying place should be altered from Rubha Garbh and “Ruardachock” on Loch Creran to Shian and the point of “Leadgrianich” – Barcaldine and Airds to build proper houses for accommodating travellers upon their respective sides of the Ferry as good as those on each side of Rudha Garbh – new line of road to be marked at – committee appointed to examine the expediency of erecting a ferry at Creran and Dallachoilish across Loch Creran. 333

25 June 1774 The Meeting appoint Glenure and Comby to converse with Barcaldine anent bringing the Ferry from Rubha Garbh to Eriska in place of Shian as proposed by the meeting 341

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License